SirFoxx wrote: Tue Sep 21, 2021 6:14 am
God I wish we could damp out the whole transmission fragility flame...yes, they
can blow up if you are
reaallllly dumb with them. But, we have yet to see one let go from sheer power alone.
we can not really address a pure power failure of the trans because these cars never came with much power. but there have been people on this forum that have had the fifth gear disintegrate when towing a small trailer, and we have also seen on this forum someone who had the gear cluster explode when backing up, and with the car still rolling backwards, put it in gear and accelerate forward. both of these conditions over loaded the gear box. there were also several forum members who had the front diff input shaft (trans output) shear off from off road use, and more than a few had the main input shaft get corn cobbed. There have also been several examples of failed front cv axles, including the spine shaft getting sheared off inside the front diff housing. some of this is likely due to low gear oil not getting lubrication up the front drivetrain, but it still hints at a gear box that can not handle a lot more power.
it would be difficult to find examples of T4wd trans that have been damaged by over powering it, since there are not that many examples of high engine output T4wds. getting much more power out of the 3a/4a engine takes a lot of effort, or a swap up to the 4age. examples of those are few and far between as it is. the 3a engine is not particularly reliable as it came from the factory, it does not have a reputation as good as the other Toyota engines, and there was never a large aftermarket demand for performance parts for the 3a, unlike the Honda, Mazda, and early Nissan counterparts. so there was never a good bolt on engine up grade package available to give the trans a good work out.
but I am with you on the trans not being as weak as their history suggests. I think with a good condition trans, or a recent rebuilt one up to factory specs, ran with a good mix of synthetic gear oil, and perhaps with some moly additive, it should hold up fairly well for up to perhaps 110hp at the flywheel, perhaps more. if the driver is always careful with the clutching and shifting, to apply power smoothly (as one should anyway), and not abuse it with adolescent "speed shifting" or towing too much, should make it hold up a long time. it seems to me one could also add an external oil cooler and perhaps a filter to keep the gear oil clean and cool. I have heard there are aftermarket trans filer/cooler kits that include an electric oil pump that can be adapted to the tercel gear box, but I would not think that would be necessary unless you will be racing it or using it in hot climates in a very aggressive way off road.
the rear axle should handle it, since it was originally designed as the main drive axle for the slightly larger RWD corolla, I have not heard of a lot of problems with the rear diff hat can not be traced back to neglected maintenance (leaky seal ignored). Too bad there is no easy LSD conversion for this size diff, it should take the extra loads on the Tercel4wd fine.
I think too, you are coming to these cars without a lot of long term experience with the Tercel4wd. Some of us on this forum have had many decades driving the T4wd, several had owned them from new (and have now passed away and can not contribute any more). I have owned and worked on over 20 Tercel4wd, about half had serious transmission issues. I have not had that kind of problem with any other cars I have owned or worked on. That is over 50 years of working on cars: the first car I bought was in 1974, and have since had experience with many Japanese brands, European cars, and a number of US made cars and trucks, in addition to other Toyota models. Sure, if people actually changed the gear oil in the trans, and had them checked for leaks like they should, it may not have been as bad, but this is a common condition with all used cars. I owned a '87 nissan pathfinder I drove 375,000 miles and neglected to ever change the oil, and sold it with the original clutch still in it working good. I my wife drove a Mazda MPV 4x4 van about 250,000 miles, auto trans, and we also neglected to change the ATF when we should have, yet it lasted longer than most Tercel4wd transmissions. it is easy to forget when it runs fine, and you always have other pressing issues to deal with. I do not know what else you need for proof, detailed study and break down of all causes of Tercel4wd transmission failures? you will never find that. cars develop a reputation usually with a good reason. the trans on the Tercel4wd is fragile, but workable with care. how much power you can push through it without it bundling up is a question most of us who have been on this forum for decades do not want find out. The cost and consequence is very high.
ignore the collective experience of those on this forum as you wish, you may be pleasantly surprised. or we might be saying "told you so" in only a few weeks. good luck.